Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Welcome to The 'Spill!
An open-to-all music blog which originated from the Guardian Readers Recommend community.
Mp3s are for sampling purposes only, and are kept up for a short time only. Mail us if any need to be removed.
-
▼
2009
(1225)
-
▼
October
(123)
- It's spooky time!!!!
- Lunacy
- I know what my costume will be tonight
- Double Caption Competition
- "Le voyage dans la lune" - George Méliès
- Au Clair de La Lune...
- a soul cake, a soul cake...
- Separated at Birth?
- For the birds
- O say can you see? Oh wait, that's the other guys
- It's Lunacy I tell you, the Moon is driving us crazy!
- Gremlin in Bärlin
- Blue Moon (or how trying to find an amusing pictur...
- What's all this then?
- Moon - Cheese - Mouse
- Moon at the Holiday Inn
- Walking On The Moon
- Dipping in and out ...
- What's Everyone Listening To Right Now This Second...
- Gong - the new album 2032
- Grown up songs - for the over 75's!
- Tipping Point Ahead
- RR Northern Social CD Compilations
- RT solos gone
- Backing a winner
- Major Tom, We Don't Need You Any More
- Getting The Hang
- AOTW: Gene Clark - No Other
- three bad men, and true
- Eye candy for (older) women
- STORYTIME - UFO'S
- Late Solo
- Solo ... it's off the radar and disappeared withou...
- The astounding eyes of Rita
- EOTWQ: Who Dat? Live at Leeds
- Playing With Yourself
- ..and I just can't hide it..
- going SOLO
- Readers Recommend?
- Bring Me Solo (& the Wookie too).
- That decides it then....
- I Bloody Love The Raveonettes
- Elmo Hope
- The Keeper
- RZA Special
- Wednesday's end of the week questions.
- ... we've even tried putting viagra in it - but it...
- Short arses of the world unite...
- Tsiganiiii!
- Tinny Mix-Tapes
- Over hill over dale, Spill music is never stale
- New Charlotte Gainsbourg (avec Beck!)
- yup, well taller
- Give 'em an Inch ...
- The Banjo: an appreciation
- slap dash for no cash
- DALI + DISNEY
- Lest auld aquaintance songs be forgot
- Juice it
- Baaallin'
- The Root of all Evil
- Rich Diverus he made a feast
- Money Rocks Quiz
- It's All Mine
- Aren't Holidays Brilliant?
- Roses are red, violets are just gonna wilt and the...
- I bought it just because I liked the cover
- Orchestre Poly Rythmo de Cotonou
- Seattle radio station listeners pick top 60 cover ...
- Caption Competition Time! V&A Special!
- EOTWQ's
- Blast From The Past #1 - 1987 : Somebodys Brother
- Are You Getting Enough Sax?
- It's just words, and music - isn't it?
- Timing is
- image? check! Words? check! Links? check! Must be ...
- The SAPD have received a complaint
- Deeper Into Movies.
- Lazy Line Painter Sane
- For Kalyr + Toffeeboy no comments necessary
- Songs for a Lazy Day
- Not exactly Carole's AOTW but an album worth revis...
- Lazy weekend for gremlinfc...
- Dolorean's Hannibal, MO
- Septober, Octember . . . it's the autumn of our da...
- For some, October is the cruellest month. October ...
- Whining ways ...
- Lazy...pun department?
- How To Make An R&B Video For Eighty Quid
- ZZZZZZZZZZ
- The three-toed duck-billed rhinopotamus
- Just in case ..........
- how viol!
- Leeds Northern Social, Saturday 24 October
- Ooo, ooo, I've got another one
- EOTWQs, too orangey for crows...
- All Apologies
- A Modest Medical Proposal
- Apocalypse Now!
- I did camera for most of this video, hope you like...
-
▼
October
(123)
Scottish BaMS Network
- ....
- Abahachi
- AliMunday
- BalearicBeat
- BeltwayBandit
- Blimpy
- BloodyParadise
- Brian Speng
- CB
- Carole
- Catcher
- DR
- Dangerpuss
- DarceysDad
- Dominia
- Exodus
- Fintan28
- GarethI
- Makinavaja
- Marconius7
- May1366
- Mnemonic
- Noodsy
- Proudfoot
- Sarah G
- SatanKidneyPie
- ShariVari
- ShivSidecar
- Shoegazer
- SkippyisaCult
- SwiftyBoy
- TatankaYotanka
- TatankaYotanka
- Tempusfugit
- Tim (Kalyr)
- ToffeeBoy
- TonNL
- TracyK
- Zephirine
- barbryn
- bishbosh
- cauliflower
- d33pf1x
- debbym
- ejaydee
- el derino
- fourfoot
- glasshalfempty
- goneforeign
- gordonimmel
- gremlinfc
- junks
- magicman
- nilpferd
- rwrrwr
- saneshane
- scarymonster
- severin
- snadfrod
- sourpus
- steenbeck
- swissphil
- tarxien
- tincanman
- tincanman2010
- treefrogdemon
Donds? Dondling? A Dondle?
The Greatest (Music Lists) Book Ever Written!
How to..
Not sure about the computery stuff involved in posting?
81 comments:
Thanks Ed - is there a way of moving the moon-based posts from down below up here or is that too much like hard work?
Pour encourager les autres, here's my provisional Moon list:
Everything But The Girl – Shadow On A Harvest Moon
Colourbox – The Moon Is Blue
Microdisney – Moon
Kirsty MacColl – Mamba De La Luna
Eels – Climbing To The Moon
Hurrah! – How High The Moon?
Belle & Sebastian – Waiting For The Moon To Rise
10,000 Maniacs – Back O’ The Moon
ejaydee said...
Alright then:
This Is How We Walk On the Moon Arthur Russell
The Moon Cat Power
My Moon My Man Feist
The Killing Moon (Up All Night Mix) Echo & The Bunnymen
Blue Moon Billie Holiday
There's A Moon Out Tonight Capris
Fly Me To The Moon Julie London
Marquee Moon Television
Moon Shadow Labelle
Walking On The Moon Rev. Jamel & Bob Johnson
Moonlight In Vermont w/ Ray Bryant Betty Carter
Havana Moon Chuck Berry
Destination Moon Norman Connors
Han Kake Gatsu (A Half Moon) Tachiko Hatouyama
Moonlight In Vermont Sam Cooke
Trip II The Moon (Kaleidoscopiklimax) Acen
Moon Mist Duke Ellington
Moon Dreams Miles Davis
Whitey On The Moon Gil Scott-Heron
No Moon At All Nat King Cole
Lua De Saõ Jorge Caetano Veloso
Banho De Lua (Tintarella Di Luna) Os Mutantes
Lua Lua Lua Caetano Veloso
Tonada De Luna Llena Caetano Veloso
Lunar Funk The Fabulous Counts
Luna Fanfarlo
Clair De Lune Isao Tomita
October 29, 2009 5:56 PM
I think I may have forgotten to say Shining Moon by Cowboy Junkies as well as their Crescent moon. Did anybody else say those? This is going to drive me crazy.
One the same as you, steen, but a different version.
Moon Gone Down by the Gourds
Moon Shines Bright by Shirley and Dolly Collins
Kiko And The Lavender Moon by Los Lobos
Spanish Moon by Little Feat
No More The Moon Shines On Lorena by Kevin Russell
Lovers’ Moon by Any Trouble
Midnight Moonlight by the Be Good Tanyas
Fever Moon by Diana Jones
Teenage Moon by the Big Bopper
Moonlight Baby by Buddy Holly
Rising For The Moon by Fairport Convention
Half Mad Moon by Damnations TX
Gringo Honeymoon by Robert Earl Keen
Full Moon by Sandy Denny
Once In A Blue Moon by Norma Waterson
Who Built The Moon? by Shinyribs
October 29, 2009 5:54 PM
Why don't you just copy the content of all the posts you don't want on your thread into one post here and then delete them, TB.
You probably don't need to copy Anonymous' post, though.
Of course there's always Keith Moon.
Ha, no-one else will have this:
La Luna Fue Culpable (And It Didn't Even Bring Me Down) by Doug Sahm and the Sir Douglas Quintet
Some handy notes for potential RR posters. The following songs with the word 'moon' in the title are already zedded:
Climbing To The Moon - Eels
Clouds Across The Moon - The RAH Band
Fly Me To The Moon - Julie London
Marquee Moon - Television
Orange Moon - Erykah Badu
Sail To The Moon - Radiohead
Whitey On The Moon - Gil Scott Heron
Suprisingly, Blue Moon is not there! I seem to remember suggesting many moons ago (see what I did there!!!) that we could have a top ten consisting solely of versions of Blue Moon. So, for starters I'll put forward:
The Marcels
The Cowboy Junkies (Blue Moon Revisited)
Jonathan Richman (instrumental)
While we're waiting for the main course, anyone else care to add to the list?
Gotta go get Malcolm, if the blog goes up early, can somebody announce it on here?
@ nilpferd - I tried that but it was more than the allowed number of characters - even without anonymous's enlightening contribution!
Surely will, steen - though PaulMac's already confessed his mistake on the mothership, so I doubt that it will.
Help, I'm going to have to stay up, aren't I?
I'm going to try nilpferd's suggestion of copying the posts over here - one at a time ...
Joe Cocker - The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. It's mine I tell you...
I think it could be another very big theme but unlike last week's it will at least be cohesive and meaningful.
If I could put my towel on just one deckchair, I think it would be Back O' The Moon by 10,000 Maniacs. Listening to it now - gorgeous ...
Is everyone else making a list of moon songs? I don't like when it goes up early but you can't actually comment.
I want Sun Moon Stars - Mos Def
Blue Moon of Kentucky - Bill Monroe
and so so many others.
Here's my preliminary list... I know people hate lists, but when you post the topic early, that's what happens.
Blue Moon of Kentucky – Bill Monroe
Waiting for the Moon to Rise – Belle and Sebastian
What a Little Moonlight Can Do – Billie Holiday
Blue Moon
I Wished on the Moon –
Meet Me In the Moonlight Alone – Carter Family
No More Moon Shines on Lorena
Moon, Turn the Tides – Jimi Hendrix
Dancing in the Moonlight – King Harvest
Sun, Moon, Stars – Mos Def
Sail to the Moon – Radiohead
Skinhead Moonstomp – The Specials or Symarip
Moon Rocks – Talking Heads
Whitey On the Moon – Gil Scott Heron, but I think it’s zedded
Grapefruit Moon – Tom Waits
Drunk on the Moon
Walking on the Moon – The Police
@ steenbeck
I know people hate lists
Errr... I though that's what we were all here for!
;0)
I'm already retracting Moon River and Spanish Moon, not sure about How High The Moon. Wasn't Skinhead Moonstomp zedded for youth cults?
Moon Palace by LUNA
(how good is that double wammy!)
dond to colourbox
A few more...Maybe somebody has already said them...
Dia Luna DIa Pena—Manu Chao
Luna y Sol
Astronomy – Black Star
Man on the Moon – REM
Werewolf - Cat Power
It would be funny if he decided to change the topic, or if it was some specific aspect of the moon none of us are thinking of.
Wow, I was just looking for Mos Def's Sun Moon Stars lyrics and I found this track.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8KO-9PHx2rg
Who knew he was in a group with his little brother and sister? I didn't.
Nope, not done The Moon before. We've only had Celestial Bodies and Sci-fi And Space. Completely different territory....
And can someone point me to the column and topic, please? I can't find them. I'm lost in space.
Oh! Did anyone say Fly me To THe MOon. I used to LOVE that song. I guess I know the Frank Sinatra version, but I'm sure there are others.
I like the pizzicato in Julie London's version.
WHitey On The Moon was indeed zedded, for historical events.
I made a post dedicated to this strange intertheme period.
Chris:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/series/readersrecommend
I've found Mark68's post with the solos list (see below). It does look rather like a 'safe bet' list to me. No RT and Dark Star included when I went to great pains to point out that what makes that track remarkable is that it is a collaboration rather than a collection of solos. Anyway, back to the bottom of the space barrel...
'Super Solos:'
1. Voodoo Child (Slight Return) - Jimi Hendrix;
2. Like a Hurricane - Neil Young and Crazy Horse;
3. Giant Steps - John Coltrane;
4. Sophisticated Lady - Duke Ellington;
5. Walk on the Wild Side - Jimmy Smith;
6. Beat It - Michael Jackson;
7. Dark Star - Grateful Dead;
8. I Feel For You - Chaka Khan;
9. New Year's Day - U2;
10. Jacqueline - Durutti Column
Jazzers love the moon.
@ Chris - please tell me you're not protesting about the inclusion of a Greatful Dead song on the A-List!!!??
:0)
Perversely, TB, yes I am. IMHO what makes it a piece of grate music is the interplay between the instrumentalists, not the individual trips it contains.
I truly didn't think to nominate it last week and found myself almost buking englishhermit's proposal.
No pleasing some people, is there?!
(Maybe Paul's column will explain that he had a Deadhead conversion whilst listening to DS and, although he fully agrees that it isn't really about solos, he just had to put it in the list because it is just so fantastic....)
I didn't know about thew Mos Def brotherhood group, it looks like there's a whole album.
THis is cool too:
http://www.worldstarhiphop.com/videos/video.php?v=wshh2xsKppvrWXeCM72D
What theme announcement?
Has Paul already posted for tomorrow?
Just the A-list and the topic, Carole.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/series/readersrecommend
Ha! Seen it.
I can't say that I particularly agree with the inclusion of any of the songs.
Not Jimi's best solo, not Neil Young's either and I agree 100% with Chris that Dark Star is not about the solos.
DS is all about the interplay.
I hate Wacko Jacko with a deep abiding passion too and I can't stand Eddie Van Halen as a guitarist - no emotion at all.
@toffeeboy
I have Blue Moon by Ian McCulloch, Simon Boswell & Alex James (all on the same track not separately!
@ Toffeeboy
REM do a decent Blue Moon
Neville Brothers - Yellow Moon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=depfUO1fmVI
and
New Moon Over My Shoulder - Doc Watson
There's a new moon over my shoulder and an old love still in my heart
I remember now that I'm older what you told me the day we had to part ...
OK - the 'Spill Blue Moon A-List gathers pace:
1. The Marcels
2. REM
3. Iam McCulloch, Simon Boswell & Alex James
4. Cowboy Junkies (BM Revisited)
5. Jonathan Richman (instrumental)
6. ?
7. ?
8. ?
9. ?
10. ?
Keep 'em coming ...
There's Billie Holiday too.
Oh, and Pink Moon - Nick Drake
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXnfhnCoOyo
absolute classic
(that's one yellow and one pink so far).
By the way, DsD is NOT HAPPY.
Donds for "The Killing Moon" definately!
Think I may have to listen to it right now!
ooooh, the Pavement version is on Spotty - haven't heard that in ages!
There's a moon in the sky called the moon.
The B-52's – There's A Moon In The Sky (Called The Moon): http://open.spotify.com/track/0t4ZrOmjVoj1TqTUIBIpSg
My mate Quique's nephew in Buenos Aires has a band and one of their songs is about the moon.
Bizarros - Persiguiendo La Luna
It's already in the box. I'm so excited to be able to nom it I may even stay up for MFF!
If anyone wants to post mine feel free, I'm not planning on staying awake till Midnight.
In the couple of hours since I was given the heads-up about that solo A-list, I have not calmed down about it at all.
You know that I have previously commented on more than one occasion about how much I like PaulMac's style etc.?
Well on this list specifically, I think the bare bones Ten, without seeing his column, misses the boat SS-S-SO-OOOO badly it doesn't even register on the passenger list!
I dunno, maybe it's because I felt so passionately about the topic itself; maybe it's because I didn't get as much time to comment as I'd have liked ...
This honestly isn't about making the A-list - if Marconius is a bit slack with his reading, he might even (mis)credit me with the hateful Beat It - this is, or bloody well should have been, about the solos.
Donds for the comments above about the Dead & Hendrix; the same logic applies to Stevie Wonder on I Feel For You. I can't comment on Coltrane or Ellington, and I actually would have included Like A Hurricane, BUT what on earth is the question that New Year's Day or f**kin' Beat It are the best answers to?!?!?!?!
I doubt I'll be able to control myself even once I've read the column, so don't expect me on RR tonight: I don't want to shit on my own doorstep . . .
I completely feel the same way, DsD.
Having f*cking U2 on a list of solos defies logic.
The Edge may well have his attractions as a player for some people but as a soloist? Nah!
Can't decide if all this premature listing has spoilt the RR fun for this week? Last time this happened was Colours week, when there were plenty of tunes to go round. Given the JAPlike length of some of these lists, suspect that all the low hanging fruit will be gobbled up in a few minutes after the blog post. Perhaps we should have a pig as our mascot? Nothing to be done now that the secret is out, but anticipate a lot of moaning from many of the regulars.
Still have a few up my sleeve, though. & there's always Halloween tunes.
Dsd- why can't you comment on Giant Steps or Sophisticated Lady? If it's because you haven't heard them, both are on Spotify.. though I'm not sure which of the versions of Sophisticated Lady Paul meant. There's only one Giant Steps, though- on the album of the same name. I do seem to remember you at some stage last weekend asking for a dropbox full of jazz...
I've got no beef with either Beat it, which I donded, nor with New Year's Day, though U2-wise I'd rather have gone with With Or Without You if anyone had mentioned it. It's not axetrickery as such, but I like Edge's guitar work, in a minimalist kind of way. U2 is another band whose albums I never repurchased post-emigration, but I still like them up until Zoo.
Well, I'm not going to worry about RR this week but have Dropboxed Nick Drake (Pink Moon); Billie Holiday (I Wished on the Moon); Pete Atkin (Be Careful When They Offer You The Moon); Rory Gallagher (Blue Moon of Kentucky) and John Renbourn (The Moon Shines Bright),which is an instrumental and sounds like "Old King Cole" to me. I've only got the Neville Bros on vinyl but someone else may oblige.
Ali Farka Toure and Toumani Diabate have a superb album called "In the Heart of the Moon" which I would be happy to dropbox as album of the week some time when we have enough space. It's beautiful.
That is a gorgeous album, Ali.
i bought it just after it was released and I play it a lot.
Lovely music.
shoey:
'Still have a few up my sleeve, though. & there's always Halloween tunes'
you could just werewolf it and do moon and halloween in one.
As I've already texted to Dsd, I like Jimi and Neil in there, I DO like U2, New years Day has a piano/guitar solo which 'makes' the song even if it isn't up to Blackmore's standard (and sometimes get a bit annoyed about the automatic denunciation of U2 around here, just because Bono is a bit of a pretentious twot - so what!? - they do make some good songs between them. There's 20 years worth of stuff to choose from, you know)
And there's only two Michael Jackson tracks I like and one of them is 'Beat It' - mainly because of the solo.
Anyway, there's an obvious DP track to nom tomorrow (I'm defo not staying up). I hope I'm first with it but,since it won't be chosen anyway, it doesn't matter.
Night, night.
Have to issue very belated megadonds for May's Jimmy Smith pick Walk on the wild side.. that's a fantastic Oliver Nelson band and chart behind him, I didn't see the nom on RR, just caught up with it now.
It's a great track and an awesome solo.
And come on people, so what if RR is up early or you don't like last week's A-list.. there are so many noses out of joint already, both here and on the mothership.. get it sorted, have some fun...
There's 20 years worth of stuff to choose from, you know
I have to disagree, gordonimmel. I haven't liked anything U2 have released since Rattle and Hum and some of that album is rubbish.
The only entirely decent album they did was The Unforgettable Fire and that came after some dreadful second-rate Simple Minds style rabble rousing on the earlier albums.
As you can tell, I don't care for them much.
!!! - "Must Be The Moon" is the most obvious moon song I can think of.
As you lot still insist on clinging to that archaic daylight savings time and the clocks have gone back over there, i'm going to miss my only chance (the first few pages) to get onto RR this week....anyone is welcome to the above nomination!
I'll dond nilpferd's last comment.
And @Carole Bristol, you've picked up on what my comment was about. I don't think much of their stuff since 'Rattle Yer Bum' either, but there is an awful lot of their work to pick and choose from.....
Ow-OOOO...werewolves of London. Zedded, unfortunately.
OK, this is silly. I have to go to a very boring conference tomorrow and if I go to sleep in the middle it will look bad. If you would kindly post my list, steenbeck, that'd be great and I will do the justifications later. It is:
Moon Gone Down by the Gourds
The Moon Shines Bright by Shirley and Dolly Collins
Kiko And The Lavender Moon by Los Lobos
Spanish Moon by Little Feat
No More The Moon Shines On Lorena by Kevin Russell
Lovers’ Moon by Any Trouble
Midnight Moonlight by the Be Good Tanyas
Fever Moon by Diana Jones
Teenage Moon by the Big Bopper
Moonlight Baby by Buddy Holly
Rising For The Moon by Fairport Convention
Half Mad Moon by Damnations TX
Gringo Honeymoon by Robert Earl Keen
Full Moon by Sandy Denny
Once In A Blue Moon by Norma Waterson
Who Built The Moon? by Shinyribs
La Luna Fue Culpable (And It Didn't Even Bring Me Down) by Doug Sahm with the Sir Douglas Quintet
Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival
Je Serai Ta Lune by Gabriel Yacoub
Goodnight everyone!
I will gladly do that, TFD, but it's got to be only minutes away.
I really feel short-changed by the Solo A-list.
I wasn't going to play but I was persuaded to change my mind and I wasn't really expecting to get any picks, but that isn't the point really.
The list is LAZY, that's the problem. I have never criticised a list before but this one is just lame, unadventurous and pretty uninspiring and, yes, I have heard Giant Steps and Sophisticated Lady.
This is bearing in mind my love for the Dead, Neil Young and Hendrix.
nilpferd: I bagzee
"...look, the moon..." (Diahnne's)
"...look, the moon..." (Carmen's) by Kip Hanrahan
have some fun... he he!
there's the column:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/oct/29/readers-recommend-super-solo-songs
no new blog yet, though.
Hear hear, Carole, HEAR BLOODY HEAR!! And I have the 12" of New Year's Day as well as around half of U2's albums; I own most of Eddie Van Halen's output. Hell I don't even think Beat It is the best guitar solo on a Wacko record, but this list is so shoddy I can only see it as an insult to my intelligence. Given my love for RR, that's why I'm so bloody cross! As you can see, i'm calming down nicely ... NOT!
@ nilpferd - yes it is because I haven't heard them, but not for a lack of desire to. Between a very busy domestic week (half-term hols) and an inundated music week (Social CDs, Dropboxed selections, an mp3 player to fill for a present, and barbryn's AOTW pick - which I haven't forgotten), I just haven't had time to even think about the Spotify or 'Boxed Solo lists.
GAH!
... And that column doesn't make me feel ANY better about anything.
!"£$%^&*(&^^%$£$%^&*ing (*&^%$£$%^&s!
Minutes away, I foolishly said. I'm going to have to go upstairs in a few minutes. So if I don't make it over the top, boys, here's my list, and don't forget TFD...
Blue Moon of Kentucky – Bill Monroe
Waiting for the Moon to Rise – Belle and Sebastian
What a Little Moonlight Can Do – Billie Holiday
Blue Moon – Billie Holiday
I Wished on the Moon – Billie Holiday
Meet Me In the Moonlight Alone – Carter Family
No More Moon Shines on Lorena
Moon, Turn the Tides – Jimi Hendrix
Dancing in the Moonlight – King Harvest
Sun, Moon, Stars – Mos Def
Sail to the Moon – Radiohead
Skinhead Moonstomp – The Specials or Symarip
Moon Rocks – Talking Heads
Whitey On the Moon – Gil Scott Heron, but I think it’s zedded
Grapefruit Moon – Tom Waits
Drunk on the Moon – Tom Waits
Walking on the Moon – The Police
Pink Moon – duh
Dia Luna DIa Pena—Manu Chao
Luna y Sol
Astronomy – Black Star
Man on the Moon – REM
Werewolf – Cat Power
The Moon – Cat Power
UTD – Moon in Cancer
Shining Moon – Cowboy Junkies
Crescent Moon – Cowboy Junkies
There’s a Moon in the Sky Called the Moon – B52s
Paper Moon – Ella Fitzgerald
Um, it's not the list I would have made myself either... but then, isn't it always like this? With lyrics-based topics, you get something "objective" to focus on, so those are somewhat more agreeable. But solos are all about subjectivity. For instance, some people hate solos full stop. For the life of me, I don't get how that can be possible, but that's the way it is.
This is a good week to make a list with two hundred good songs on it. It's a terrible list to make an A-list two of us can agree on, though, (let alone more people). That's the way I see it, at least...
Lamretinha, you are a very calming voice of reason. (You too, Nilpferd) I had a dream last night that we spent a month somewhere ridiculously central in Europe so that we could meet everybody, so WATCH OUT!
Sigh. It seems cruel to put the subject up 5 hours early, and then not put the blog up till who-knows-when. It's like the other night, when Isaac woke me up in the middle of the night for a cuddle, and then I looked at the clock by his bed and thought, ah...2am, plenty of time to sleep. But they'd played with the clock and it was actually 7 am, but it's dark this time of year and we all had to get up in the cold and dark. Just cruel.
Cruel, you say? It's 1:03 AM here already...
Yawn!
Sorry, Lambrethinha, it's all relative of course. I'm off to put the boys to bed, so...if it's up...
Sigh...
There it is...
Hmmm, "Pig" was a little strong, although a little editing or restraint or editing would go a long way, people. I'm not pointing out tfd or toffee who's taste is more (respectfully) on the margins. I am calling out Magicman, EJ (apart from the more obscure "world music" stuff that we wouldn't hear without your introduction. Thank you.) and Ladysteen. Agree with Nilpferd that the Hippo way should be followed, but also think that our community should be self-policing, and that we should raise issues as & when they occur. Am worried that we are heading for: "I would like to recommend the following 350 songs".
Can understand DsD & Carole's frustration & agree that the trad rock community got the short-end this week. Can't argue with the jazz picks & was pleased to see Vini in the A-list.
Carole: buking over U2 or Simple Minds does nothing to help your cause. Despite periods of turgidity, some of us fond of them. No hard feelings, though.
I don't really have a "cause" Shoey, I was (and still am) really annoyed by the cautious and unadventurous list, Dark Star notwithstanding.
Reading the column hasn't helped either.
Mind you, if you think my dislike of U2 is a bit partisan, consider what my feelings would have been if Travis, Keane or Coldplay had been listed.
IMHO, the B list is better than the A list this week, at least it has some lateral thinking.
Can't say I'm too keen on the A-List or the B-List - but then I wasn't too keen on the whole darn theme. Disappointed that The Great Gig In The Sky didn't make it (it would have been nice to see at least one example of thinking outside the box) but not really too surprised. Very disappointed that not one Jan Akkerman/Focus track made it to either list.
For those of you who care, all but two of the final ten were nominated within 15 hours of the blog being published. The three 'new' artists: Jimmy Smith, Chaka Khan and Durrutti Column are hardly cutting edge ...
"Maybe Paul's column will explain that he had a Deadhead conversion whilst listening to DS and, although he fully agrees that it isn't really about solos, he just had to put it in the list because it is just so fantastic...." I said before reading his column.
And it does seem like he got something from it. His phrase 'tapestry of solos' is actually one I rather like, as the individual instruments do weave together to create a picture.
To also learn that Sister Ray is one of his favourite tracks of all time shifted my view of him some more. Didn't he say he was a hip-hop man?
You're welcome, Shane!
Actually, I hadn't thought of those yet, so you really are welcome...
Sorry, Shoegazer.
No need to apologize, Steen.
Sorry, Shoey. (I know you excluded me on the grounds that no-one else would pick any of my suggestions anyway, but still.) I just wanted ONE opportunity to look things up in my iTunes, which I can't access at work. But it didn't feel right.
TFD, I'm sure there are other Folk-Rockers who would like to see some stuff left on the shelf - but you don't need to apologize either.
Post a Comment